60th Anniversary of Brocks Gap Dam Defeat

Smaller Gallery Image: Preparing to hug a large, old white oak near home in 2020.
Seeing the Forest for the Carbon
07/17/2023
Chris Bolgiano gives a presentation on "Our Forests, Our Future" at the Harrisonburg Rotary Club.
Harrisonburg Rotary Club Presentation
04/29/2024
Smaller Gallery Image: Preparing to hug a large, old white oak near home in 2020.
Seeing the Forest for the Carbon
07/17/2023
Chris Bolgiano gives a presentation on "Our Forests, Our Future" at the Harrisonburg Rotary Club.
Harrisonburg Rotary Club Presentation
04/29/2024
Receipt showing Garnett Turner's charter of 5 buses in September of 1963

Receipt showing Garnett Turner's charter of 5 buses in September of 1963

“60th Anniversary:  Brocks Gap Dam Proposal Lambasted!” is the true story of how a small rural community stopped a huge government agency, the Army Corp of Engineers, from drowning hundreds of homes and farms under a massive lake meant to dilute urban pollution as far downstream as Washington, D.C.  Published in the September, 2023 issue of The Chimney Rock Chronicle. I did much of the research for this story in 2008, when, as a member of the Fulks Run Ruritan Club, for its 50th anniversary I wrote The Fulks Run Ruritan Club: 1958-2008, A Documentary History, which includes a chapter on the dam with copies of letters, newspaper articles, and minutes of Club meetings 


Receipt showing Garnett Turner's charter of 5 buses in September of 1963
Receipt showing Garnett Turner’s charter of 5 buses in September of 1963

60th Anniversary: Brocks Gap Dam Proposal Lambasted!

By Chris Bolgiano for the Chimney Rock Chronicle, September 2023 issue.

On September 4, 1963, 185 people from the Brocks Gap area paid a $5 fare and packed 5 Southern Greyhound buses to attend a Congressional committee meeting in Washington, D.C.  Their mission:  stop an 860 foot-long dam from being built between the historic cliffs of Brocks Gap, through a beautiful swimming hole in the North Fork of the Shenandoah River.  Planned by the Army Corp of Engineers, the dam would be 147 feet high and create a 2,810 acre lake with 26 miles of shoreline. 

This wasn’t the first time.  In the early 1940s, Lloyd Turner (Garnett’s father) and other Fulks Run residents took a bus to Congress and convinced a committee not to build a proposed Brocks Gap dam.  But that was during WWII, when there were other priorities.

By the 1960s, rapid development around metropolitan Washington prompted the Army Corp to design a series of dams up the Potomac River and into the Shenandoah Valley.  The Brocks Gap dam would hold 61 billion gallons of water, to be drawn down as needed to dilute pollutants and sewage discharged by industries and municipalities downstream.  It would also, the Corp wrote in its report, provide flood control plus recreational swimming and boating areas for at least 200,000 visitors annually, and still – somehow – preserve drinking water quality.  “I remember when the Brocks Gap Dam was being discussed,” said Tammy Cullers (native of Fulks Run and editor of this paper).  “I was a very young child, but the thought terrified me!”

Garnet Turner and the Fulks Run Ruritans organized the bus trip.  Herman Turner, a Fulks Run native and owner of Turner Electric Company in Timberville, was the spokesman.  He included the text of his speech in his 1998 book, The Turner Mill.  In it, he rebutted the Army Corp’s many errors, such as the undercount of families to be moved (120 to the actual 312).  “A closely knit farm community would have to be moved,” he said.  Where to? Would the land be taken from others?  “We do not appreciate the methods used by the Corps,” he continued.  “They are using our tax money [for] … unfair and unjust methods.” 

He also referenced studies that showed how building a number of small headwater reservoirs on various streams would offer many of the same benefits without such immense destruction.  “Some of the recommended sites are located on national forest land,” he pointed out, where no one lived.

The group’s compelling presentation to Congress was followed up by several more years of community meetings in the newly built Fulks Run Elementary School, and letter writing and local lobbying by the Fulks Run Ruritan Club.  By 1968, several small dams had been approved.  After more years of studies and permits, dams at Lagoha on the Shoemaker River and on two of its tributaries in the George Washington National Forest, Slate Lick Branch and Hog Pen Run, were built.  No one was forced to move.